In April 2009, Science retracted an article that described a technology that the authors had modestly called “MAGIC” for “MAGnetism-based Interaction Capture”. At the time, I wrote, in a post entitled “Nanoparticles: not magic after all“:
As a scientist who sometimes review papers, one of the key questions for me is: was it possible to detect the fraud at the time of submission? Can we learn something from this story about how better reviewing scientific papers. I had a fresh look at the original paper with this question in mind and the answer is not straightforward.
Reviewers do not have access to the lab books and primary evidence. In this case, the falsifications are not obvious: I don’t think that, as a reviewer, I would have suspected that the data were fabricated.
One thing however is striking: the paper reported extraordinary (magical?) results far from what was at the time the state of the art. To take just one example, the technique viability supposed a perfect control on the cytosolic delivery of functional nanomaterials: 4 years later, this is still a field of active investigation and such a control is far from being routinely attained. Yet, in the 2005 paper, claims over of such a control were accepted without the backing of a serious experimental investigation, e.g. no electron microscopy images of the nanoparticles inside the cells were presented.
The paper went several steps ahead of the state of the art (and that’s why it was interesting for Science)… and some of the first steps were poorly (or not) documented, while the last step was documented with fabricated data. Maybe questioning these first steps would have allowed detecting the problem? or maybe not…
In February 2018, I asked on PubPeer the same question to the authors of a (then) recently published Nature Communication article – how did you get nanoparticles to the cytosol? The article reported fantastic (magic?) nanoparticles that would enter cancer cells, and, under IR irradiation, prevent the production of ATP thus making drug-resistant cancer cells vulnerable again. I did not get any response, but other comments followed. One asked another scientific question and in 2022 Actinopolyspora biskrensis found image duplications in Fig 7, S12 and S29. Now, eight years after publication, eight years after my unanswered question, four years after the duplications were found, the paper has been retracted following an institutional investigation.
I told that latter story recently on LinkedIn and noted that such cases demonstrated the benefit of being a PubPeer user (at the minimum of having installed the extension in your web browser). In a response to a PubPeer critic, I argued that my 2018 question (and the absence of an answer from the authors) as well as the observed duplications in figures were additional context valuable to readers for their own critical evaluation of the paper. Those readers may, for example, be PhD students whose project is partly based on that publication: without the PubPeer extension, they would not have been aware of those concerns and may have wasted months or years before realising the problems. I concluded my LinkedIn comment with a “tantalising question”:
What is the proportion of the thousands of articles where endosomal escape of nanoparticles is assumed without justification or explanation actually contains fraudulent data?
I cannot answer this question just yet (and probably won’t ever be able to do so quantitatively) but our post-publication peer review effort demonstrates its relevance since most articles that report the detection of intracellular cytosolic targets using nanoparticle probes do not demonstrate endosomal escape nor do they even mention the problem. We also identified image dupli cations and other serious issues in several of those articles. Further evidence of the role of data manipulation in the growth of this information bubble comes from the first results of our replication initiative.
From a practical point of view, systematically asking authors (on PubPeer or in peer review reports) to fill large methodological gaps would be a good practice for readers and peer reviewers of articles; it would contribute to identify common misconceptions sometimes based on, or amplified by, research misconduct.








